Publications and Research
Document Type
Other
Publication Date
Winter 3-4-2025
Abstract
Twenty-seven years after the IIRAIRA in New York City, that iconic destination of migrants has undergone extraordinary challenges to its status as a welcoming refuge to the tired and teeming masses of the globe. In this article, based on recent qualitative and quantitative research, we trace the policing of its migrant communities as the U.S. state has resorted to increasingly punitive measures to regulate the lives of non-citizens regarded as deportable aliens within the rubric of contemporary immigration laws. Findings from the research show that while the city with its long history of immigrant advocacy has in part resisted the exclusionary pressures of the security state (e.g. in 2014 it was the first city to fund universal representation for migrants in removal proceedings and became a sanctuary city while refusing to participate in ICE’s 278(g) program), its most criminalized black and migrant communities still produce the highest rates of removal we describe as the deportation pipeline. We argue that New York City while often held up as a model of immigrant integration is in effect a highly contested socio-political, economic, and cultural space caught between the forces of exclusion and inclusion overdetermined by processes of crimmigration. As migrants become socially constructed along a continuum of “good and bad,” “deserving and undeserving,” they also become policed across both internal and external borders. We conclude that such policing processes resonate criminologically with the concept of “social bulimia,” a major characteristic of late modern capitalistic society.
